Thursday, 13 June, 2024, Reg No- 06
Advance Search


Reviewed by Giraj Sharma

Published : Saturday, 8 June, 2024 at 12:00 AM  Count : 582



This book involving the infamous incident between Boria Majumdar and Wridhiman Saha and the resultant ban on the journalist is about closure to a most trying period in his life…

A cricketer promises an interview to a leading sports journalist, historian and show host but keeps him waiting till late at night. This is an interview for which the journalist sets aside two other important interviews as he wanted to respect an earlier commitment to this cricketer. Its late in the evening, well past dinner time when it dawns on the journalist that he has been ghosted - left in the lurch by a cricketer whom he considered a friend and a fellow Bengali. In a moment of despair and frustration, he shoots out messages that the cricketer construes as ullying and all hell breaks loose. The cricketer goes to town with his sob story on Twitter (X) and a huge trial by social media begins. To add to the journalists woes, there is the stuff thats playing in the background.

The cricketer has been dropped from the Indian team earlier and the entire narrative is built by the troll army insinuating that it was at the journalists behest that cricketer has got dropped from the national side.

The cricketer who tweeted was Wridhiman Saha and the journalist being accused was none other than Boria Majumdar. BCCI took cognizance of the incident and formed a three member committee to probe the threat messages sent out to Saha for declining an interview. It resulted in the BCCI imposing a two-year ban on Boria Majumdar because the BCCIs three-member committee found him guilty.

The book, Banned, is about how life changed for Boria Majumdar and how he coped with all the insults and abuses he was subjected to on social media by the troll army. Pleads Boria in the book that his messages may have been inappropriately worded in the frustration of the moment, but they were never ever intended as a threat, or any kind of harm.
Credit is due to Boria for having kept quiet for two years of the ban and having respected the judgment, in letter and spirit, even if it was erroneous. The toll, however, that the ban took on him and his family was heavy - and thats putting it mildly. Besides the trauma of trial by social media where there are no rules and no boundaries, Boria ran the risk of a huge financial impact. His company Revsportz was all about sports and here he was almost declared persona non grata by the most influential cricketing board in the world and the most powerful sports body in India.

Banned is about closure. First there was this self-doubt in Borias mind and the uphill tasks of picking up the pieces and moving on. Then there was a need to make his enterprise survive because there were careers of his teammates at Revsportz at stake. Coupled with it all was the agony of feeling as an outcast due to the actions of some members of his fraternity. His feelings are best expressed when he asks how did professional competition become stiffer than the brotherhood one had shared? By his own admittance, writing this book was a way to channel his angst and to find solace. That Boria and his family suffered a lot is established in the initial chapters and the writing evokes empathy too but the repetition of the sufferings gets a bit too much for the reader. Beyond a point it appears to be a rant of a wounded journalist which has limited appeal for the reader who would rather be served more trivia about sporting icons.

Of course, Banned has some little pearls nested in the text - that of sport legends standing by Boria and supporting him and his company for they had seen his work for over two decades before the ill-fated ban happened. There is a cute little story on how badminton guru Pullela Gopichand offered to launch Borias book Maverick Commissioner when Boria felt that no sportsperson would touch him with a bargepole. Then there are instances of support for his show Breakfast With Boria where stars such as Sourav Ganguly, Gautam Gambhir, and Shoaib Akhtar came on the show for the World Cup in 2023 pro bono. In fact, the list of sports stars who supported Boria during the two years is long and includes legends such as Michael Clarke, Abhinav Bindra, Neeraj Chopra, Anju Bobby George, Mirabai Chanu, Deepa Malik and many more.

Intriguingly, Boria doesn bring up Sahas name at all and refers to him as The Cricketer (Saha had not named Boria in the tweets but did so in the BCCIs committees hearing thus the ban). In fact, he does not reveal a lot of other names and refers to people by their job descriptions and that, at times, is a dampener for the reader. As a sports aficionado one would have loved to have more insights on the things that the sports stars told Boria to lift him up citing their own resilient pushbacks when chips were down or when they were wronged by the system - stuff that Gautam Gambhir mentions in Borias show and is reproduced in the book. That would have lifted Banned from merely being a book for the ruth being set free to a book about resilience painted on a much larger canvass.


Latest News
Most Read News
Editor : Iqbal Sobhan Chowdhury
Published by the Editor on behalf of the Observer Ltd. from Globe Printers, 24/A, New Eskaton Road, Ramna, Dhaka.
Editorial, News and Commercial Offices : Aziz Bhaban (2nd floor), 93, Motijheel C/A, Dhaka-1000.
Phone: PABX- 41053001-06; Online: 41053014; Advertisement: 41053012.
E-mail: info©, news©, advertisement©, For Online Edition: mailobserverbd©
  [ABOUT US]     [CONTACT US]   [AD RATE]   Developed & Maintenance by i2soft