
Stanford University in the United States is returning to traditional pen-and-paper examinations and restricting the use of laptops and smartphones in classrooms amid growing concerns that students are using artificial intelligence (AI) to cheat on academic assessments.
The move aims to ensure genuine evaluation of students' knowledge and improve their learning experience.
According to the university's Civic, Liberal and Global Education (COLLEGE) programme, first-year students will now be required to take quizzes in classrooms and submit handwritten essays.
Interestingly, the initiative followed students' own suggestions on how to ensure their knowledge is properly assessed amid concerns over the misuse of AI.
In its guidelines, Stanford said digital devices, including laptops, smartphones and smart glasses, could disrupt students' immediate attention and long-term learning processes. Students have therefore been advised to keep all internet-connected devices switched off and inside their bags during classes.
However, exceptions will be made for students with physical disabilities or other conditions that make handwriting difficult. In classes where a complete ban on digital devices is not feasible, teachers may allow students to use tablets in a notebook-style position, preferably in the front rows, following specific instructions.
According to a report by The Stanford Daily, the university's student newspaper, the changes have been introduced in two compulsory first-year courses: COLLEGE 101 and the Program in Writing and Rhetoric.
The new assessment methods include in-class writing, handwritten annotations and journaling.
Stanford Computer Science Professor Chris Gregg has welcomed the initiative. Amid declining classroom attendance following the rise of AI, he has also introduced small tutorial groups of three students to encourage closer academic engagement.
"Detecting cheating is extremely uncomfortable for instructors. Rather than focusing on catching students cheating, we are more interested in creating an environment where their actual abilities can be assessed," Gregg said.
He added that the new assessment approach had helped reduce cheating at the university in recent years.
Meanwhile, English professor emeritus Mark Bauerlein described AI as being contrary to the principles of humanities education. He argued that the emergence of AI had created an assumption among teachers that students would cheat whenever given the opportunity.
Jared Gould, managing editor of Minding the Campus, a publication of the National Association of Scholars, also supported Stanford's initiative. However, he cautioned that returning to handwritten examinations alone would not solve the problem unless universities also addressed grade inflation.
Gould said students were increasingly relying on AI for intellectual tasks, a practice known as cognitive offloading.
"If you don't make your brain work a little harder, you will never acquire genuine knowledge or become an educated person," he said.
He also warned that universities risked becoming institutions that simply awarded degrees without properly assessing students' reading, writing and critical-thinking abilities.
Against this backdrop, Stanford's return to traditional assessment methods is being viewed as an important step towards protecting academic standards in higher education.