বাংলা E-Paper 📍 Dhaka 📅 Friday | 20 November 2026, 5 Ogrohaeon 1433 PID registration number 06
HEADLINE
Advertisement

Why Criminal Trials in Bangladesh’s Magistrate Courts Take So Long

Published : Friday, 20 November, 2026 at 12:00 AM
Shreonti Samiha
Most criminal cases in Bangladesh begin in a Magistrate Court. The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (CrPC) sets out a clear path for these cases, from the pre-trial hearing and framing of charge to the plea, presentation of evidence, examination of the accused, and finally, acquittal or sentence. On paper, the process looks fair and straightforward. In practice, however, several gaps weaken it and often prevent justice from being delivered on time.

The Pre-Trial Hearing Is Too Narrow
Under Section 241A, a Magistrate can discharge an accused if the charge is groundless. However, in 43 DLR (AD) 63, the Appellate Division held that, at this stage, the court cannot consider the accused’s documents, an inquiry report, or even a medical certificate.
This restriction helps prevent the trial from turning into a mini-trial at an early stage. Yet, it also creates difficulties for someone facing a false or weak case. They may have to wait until the charge is framed before presenting evidence that could support their innocence. In the meantime, they may spend months in custody or remain on bail while the case continues.
Allowing limited, clearly undisputed documents, such as official records, at this stage could help courts identify and dismiss obviously false cases sooner.

Framing of Charge Can Become Routine
The next stage is framing the charge. Section 242 requires a charge to contain sufficient details of time, place and person. In reality, however, charges are sometimes framed mechanically, soon after the police report arrives, without careful consideration. This can leave the accused uncertain about the specific allegations and make it harder for them to prepare a proper defence.
To prevent this, courts should be required to give short written reasons when framing a charge. Magistrates should also receive training to examine the charges carefully rather than treating this stage as a routine formality.

The Guilty Plea May Not Be Fully Voluntary

Another concern arises when an accused person admits guilt. Section 243 allows a conviction on an admission of guilt. However, many accused persons are poor, illiterate, or unrepresented. Some may plead guilty out of fear, pressure, or simply because they want to bring a long and exhausting case to an end. Although the CrPC requires the plea to be recorded in the accused’s own words, it does not clearly require the court to confirm that the person understands the consequences of that admission.
For this reason, courts should be required to explain the charge and the likely punishment in simple language. Legal aid should also be offered before accepting a guilty plea, particularly when the accused has no legal representation.

Delay in Taking Evidence
Perhaps the biggest weakness in the process is the delay in taking evidence. Section 244 sets out the steps for presenting evidence, but it does not adequately control the time required. Witnesses often fail to appear, police witnesses are sometimes absent, and lawyers seek repeated adjournments. As a result, cases that should be resolved within a reasonable period can continue for years. Millions of cases are also reported to be pending in Bangladeshi courts, adding to the pressure on the justice system.
Such delays conflict with Article 35(3) of the Constitution, which guarantees a speedy and public trial by an independent and impartial court. A right to a speedy trial means little if cases continue indefinitely because witnesses do not appear or hearings are repeatedly postponed.
To address this, courts need strict limits on adjournments and fixed trial schedules. Stronger action against witnesses, who ignore summons, along with the use of video links to record evidence where suitable, could also help reduce unnecessary delays.

Witnesses Are Not Properly Protected
However, ensuring that witnesses attend court is only part of the challenge. They must also feel safe enough to give evidence. Trials depend heavily on witnesses, yet many in Bangladesh face threats, pressure or harassment. As far as I know, there is still no complete, dedicated witness protection law. When witnesses turn hostile out of fear, the court may lose access to important evidence, allowing guilty persons to be acquitted.
A proper witness protection law, including safe arrangements for giving testimony, is therefore necessary to ensure that witnesses can speak without fear or intimidation.

Examination of the Accused: Right to Silence vs Adverse Inference
The examination of the accused also raises concerns about the protection of individual rights. Section 342 allows the court to question the accused without prior warning. Although the accused may refuse to answer, the court may draw inferences from that refusal. This creates tension with Article 35(4) of the Constitution, which says no accused person can be forced to be a witness against themselves.
The concern is particularly serious for an unrepresented accused who may not understand that their silence could count against them. Clear guidelines are therefore needed to ensure that adverse inference is used with great care. The accused should also be informed of their options before questioning begins.

Sentencing Limits and Transfers Cause Extra Delay
Delays can also arise after a case has reached the sentencing stage. Under Sections 245 and 349, if a Magistrate considers a more severe punishment necessary than they are authorised to impose, the case goes to a higher Magistrate. Although this arrangement helps prevent a Magistrate from imposing a sentence beyond their authority, it adds another step to the process and can prolong the case.
Moreover, the CrPC offers little guidance on consistent sentencing. As a result, punishments for similar crimes can vary widely. Clearer sentencing guidelines could help promote consistency and reduce unnecessary uncertainty.

No Formal Plea Bargaining or Diversion
Another issue is the number of minor cases that occupy court time. As far as I know, the CrPC has no full system of plea bargaining or mediation for petty offences. As a result, even minor cases may go through lengthy court proceedings when they could be resolved through properly regulated alternatives.
Carefully controlled alternatives for minor, non-violent offences could help reduce the pressure on Magistrate Courts and allow them to devote more time to serious cases.

A Deeper Problem: An Old Law
These shortcomings also point to a broader concern about the age and structure of the law itself. The CrPC is more than 125 years old. Although several amendments have been made, its basic structure comes from colonial times. Modern needs, such as digital evidence, victim rights and witness safety, fit poorly into it.

At the same time, the independence of the lower judiciary remains essential. In the Masdar Hossain case (52 DLR (AD) 82), the Appellate Division ordered the separation of the judiciary from the executive. A Magistrate who is truly independent is among the strongest safeguards of a fair trial. Without that independence, even well-designed legal procedures may fail to protect the rights of ordinary people.

The steps of a Magistrate Court trial are well designed. The problem lies in time, fear, poverty and weak enforcement. A fair trial is not only about having the correct procedures in place, but also about making them work for ordinary people. Reform should focus on reducing delays, protecting witnesses and safeguarding the rights of the accused. Justice that arrives too late, or only for those who can afford it, is not full justice.

The writer is a student in the Department of Law at Bangladesh University of Professionals (BUP)


Advertisement
Loading...
Loading...
Editor : Iqbal Sobhan Chowdhury
Published by the Editor on behalf of the Observer Ltd. from Globe Printers, 24/A, New Eskaton Road, Ramna, Dhaka.
Editorial, News and Commercial Offices : Aziz Bhaban (2nd floor), 93, Motijheel C/A, Dhaka-1000.

Phone: PABX- 41053001-06; Advertisement: 41053012; 01793317829, 01550707291, 01550707296
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected]. [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], ‍[email protected], Online-email: [email protected]

🔝