
Xi Jinping’s invocation of the sword of Damocles at the reported Shenzhen summit with Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump was apt. In the Greek tale, a sword hangs over Damocles by a single horsehair, symbolising the peril beneath power’s comforts. Nuclear weapons hold humanity under a similar threat, dependent on political judgement and fragile safeguards against miscalculation.
The reported four-point declaration signals a step towards peace, but dialogue is neither settlement nor disarmament. The question is whether the three powers seek a safer, fairer world or merely an order serving their interests.
A Milestone, But of What Kind?The summit merits recognition. Never before have the leaders of the three principal nuclear powers formally met amid the Ukraine war, US-Israel-Iran tensions and strained trade ties. When diplomacy falters, a table with three chairs is better than none. On the sidelines of the APEC summit, Washington, Beijing and Moscow outlined common positions on international security, UN reform, energy, criminal jurisdiction and nuclear risk reduction, echoing the 1985 Reagan-Gorbachev rejection of nuclear war.
Yet the declaration expresses political intent, not a binding treaty. It offers no ceasefire, enforceable arms reductions, conflict-resolution mechanism or implementation timetable. Peace rhetoric alone cannot guarantee peace. The political gains are more evident: Xi projected China's global leadership, Putin regained diplomatic visibility despite Western sanctions, and Trump showcased engagement with major rivals. These gains do not necessarily advance peace.
The summit also points to an emerging ‘great-power concert’ to manage global crises. While potentially reducing miscalculation, it risks sidelining smaller nations. No secret division of the world has been established, but managing global affairs without wider participation remains a legitimate concern.
The declaration also overlooks the Rohingya crisis, offering no roadmap for safe, voluntary and dignified repatriation despite China and Russia’s influence over Myanmar and US diplomatic leverage. Climate and development finance are also absent. As an African proverb warns, when elephants fight, the grass suffers. Smaller nations need a voice in decisions affecting them, not collateral status in great-power bargains.
Anatomy of the Peace DeclarationAfter a 90-minute meeting, Xi, Putin and Trump issued a four-clause peace declaration. Its promises and omissions warrant scrutiny.
UN Reform or Preservation of Privilege: The first clause promises UN reform but offers no Security Council expansion, regional representation or veto reform. Under Article 108 of the UN Charter, amendments require a two-thirds General Assembly vote and ratification by two-thirds of member states, including all five permanent members. The three powers cannot decide alone. Bangladesh and other developing nations need equitable representation in decisions on war, sanctions and security.
Energy Cooperation without Guarantees: The second clause pledges increased production and supply of refined petroleum products but sets no targets, pricing mechanisms or safeguards against manipulation. Russian sanctions and vulnerable maritime routes remain unresolved. Diversification could strengthen Bangladesh’s energy security, but dependence on limited suppliers and routes remains a risk.
Sovereignty versus Accountability: The third clause stresses state consent and official immunity, warning against abuses of International Criminal Court (ICC) jurisdiction. The ICC issued an arrest warrant for Putin in March 2023 over alleged war crimes involving Ukrainian children. The US, outside the Rome Statute, has challenged aspects of the Court’s jurisdiction, while China prioritises sovereignty and non-interference.
Yet the declaration neither defines jurisdictional abuse nor identifies who would determine it. Articles 27 and 98 of the Rome Statute address official immunity and cooperation. Sovereignty cannot shield genocide, war crimes or crimes against humanity; justice requires judicial independence, due process and victims’ rights.
Nuclear Dialogue without Disarmament: The fourth clause echoes the 1985 Reagan-Gorbachev declaration that nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought. Yet it offers no warhead reductions, lower alert levels, independent verification, binding arms control or no-first-use commitment.
New START’s expiry in February 2026 makes the absence of a successor US-Russia arms-control framework particularly consequential. China’s smaller arsenal and distinct strategic priorities complicate its inclusion in negotiations. Cyber operations, autonomous weapons and evolving early-warning systems pose further unaddressed risks.
Risk reduction matters, but the arsenals remain intact. The sword may be steadier, but it has not been sheathed.
The Silences in a Peace DeclarationA declaration is judged by its omissions as much as its promises. It ignores Ukraine and offers no roadmap for Iran, Gaza, Taiwan or the Korean peninsula. Ceasefires, civilian protection, humanitarian access, climate change and food security are also absent.
No summit can resolve every crisis, but credible peace requires clarity about whose security it serves and consultation with affected nations. Ukraine’s future, for instance, cannot be decided without Ukrainians.
Meaningful follow-up requires a nuclear talks timetable, crisis communication channels, UN reform proposals and wider consultation. Otherwise, rhetoric risks replacing action.
When Elephants Fight, the Grass SuffersThe declaration’s weakness lies in the gap between rhetoric and commitment. It offers no concrete UN reform, petroleum targets, immunity rules or verifiable nuclear disarmament. Without implementation and monitoring, claims of a breakthrough are premature.
The summit exposes the limits of personal diplomacy. Peace requires institutions, not presidential chemistry. Shenzhen produced no ceasefire, treaty or arms reduction. All that glitters is not gold.
More troubling is the prospect of powerful states deciding smaller nations’ futures. The 1945 Yalta Conference offers a cautionary parallel. Putin’s favourable reference to Yalta and question, “What was so bad about it?”, revive fears of great-power bargains imposed without consent. No secret Shenzhen deal to divide the world has been established, but such arrangements could threaten sovereignty.
For Bangladesh, the stakes are immediate. The US is a major export market, China a key trading partner and industrial supplier, and Russia an energy and nuclear partner. Dhaka must protect trade, energy security and strategic autonomy without becoming dependent on any single power.
The declaration also overlooks the Rohingya crisis, offering no roadmap for safe, voluntary and dignified repatriation despite China and Russia’s influence over Myanmar and US diplomatic leverage. Climate and development finance are also absent. As an African proverb warns, when elephants fight, the grass suffers. Smaller nations need a voice in decisions affecting them, not collateral status in great-power bargains.
The Blade Still HangsThe Shenzhen declaration could mark a beginning if its rhetoric leads to verifiable arms limits, crisis communication and inclusive security decisions.
For now, its promises outstrip commitments: UN reform without proposals, energy cooperation without safeguards, jurisdictional restraint without clear rules and nuclear dialogue without disarmament. The UN rests on sovereign equality. Its five permanent members have special responsibilities, not a monopoly on peace. The true test is fewer weapons, stronger institutions, accountability and a voice for nations beyond the table. Until then, the sword of Damocles hangs over humanity.
The writer is a journalist at The Daily Observer