
In April 2025, Michael Clark walked out of the Boulder County Jail in Colorado and into the arms of his family after more than twelve years in prison for a 1994 murder he has always maintained he did not commit. His conviction was built partly on DNA found on a tube of lip balm near the crime scene , later he was vacated after it emerged that the evidence had been handled by a disgraced crime-lab analyst.
That analyst is Yvonne “Missy” Woods, a former DNA scientist at the Colorado Bureau of Investigation, who was sentenced to ten years in prison after pleading guilty to cybercrime, perjury, forgery and attempting to influence a public servant. Over a career spanning nearly three decades, Woods manipulated or mishandled work touching more than a thousand cases. Investigators found she had deleted DNA values and filed false reports in dozens of cases telling detectives that no male DNA existed where it actually did, quietly burying the cases of women and children who had reported sexual assaults. The sentencing judge called it intentional misconduct by a highly trained professional occupying a position of extraordinary trust.
Here is what should unsettle anyone who supports capital punishment: Clark’s case was not undone by a witness recanting or a journalist’s exposé. It collapsed because a single technician, in a single laboratory, in a system with defence counsel, discovery rules, DNA re-testing and an independent prosecutor willing to say that the duty of a prosecutor is to do justice, could not be trusted. If a wealthy, heavily scrutinised American justice system, so often held up as the gold standard of forensic adjudication , can convict a man on corrupted evidence and lock him away for twelve years, then no system on earth can claim the certainty that execution demands.
The death penalty’s entire moral claim rests on an impossible premise: infallibility. It asks us to be certain beyond all doubt, because its error is the only sentence that cannot be corrected. Imprisonment is reversible; the gallows is an admission that we have stopped listening. Clark, at least, came home. The condemned in cases Woods touched and in the countless unexamined scandals we will never know about, had no such door to walk through.
The empirical case against deterrence is now overwhelming. No serious study demonstrates that execution deters homicide more effectively than life imprisonment. Crime is shaped by policing, poverty, inequality and the speed and fairness of adjudication, none of which improves because a rope is available. What capital punishment reliably produces is its own catalogue of injustices. It is applied unequally: the poor, who cannot afford competent counsel, bear it; the well-connected rarely do. It is applied erratically: the line between a life sentence and a death sentence can turn on the mood of a court, the competence of an investigator, or the provenance of a single piece of forensic evidence. And it coarsens everything around it, every wrongful conviction discovered abroad was once declared proven beyond reasonable doubt by a judge. Beyond reasonable doubt is not the same as true. Michael Clark learned that at the cost of twelve years. The executed learn nothing at all.

It is high time that the state do the harder work: investigate properly, fund independent and accountable forensic laboratories, guarantee the accused real counsel and genuine access to evidence, and build prisons that punish without becoming monuments to failure. Life imprisonment without parole, subject to judicial review, protects the public just as surely without asking for an execution to correct the failures of a Missy Woods. Colorado itself abolished its death penalty in 2020, years before the full scale of its lab scandal surfaced. Its example suggests that a society which stops killing in the state’s name is also a society forced to take the integrity of its evidence seriously.
The complicated existence of the death penalty is, in the end, simple: it survives only where we agree not to look at its errors. Woods looked away for twenty-nine years, and a thousand cases went with her. No nation should wait for its own corrupted files and its own hanged innocents to learn what Colorado now knows. The question is not whether we are tough on the worst crimes. It is whether we are humble enough to admit that the men and women who run our courts, our laboratories and our police forces are human and that no human institution should hold the power of an irreversible sentence.
The writer is a student in the Department of Law at Bangladesh University of Professionals